American Idol Top 9 Elimination 4/7/10

I've never been more disappointed in this show! This week was Beatles week and it was yet another opportunity for the contestants to screw up other people's songs.
Crystal did awesome, as usual. Big Mike was arrogant, as usual. Casey was good, Andrew wasn't that good, Aaron was boring, Siobhan was ok- but weird, and the "others" were fine...
Bottom line: Tim Urban wasn't in the bottom three this week. It was Big Mike, Aaron Kelly, and Andrew Garcia. The shocker was when Ryan told Aaron that he was safe and it down to Big Mike & Andrew. Everyone just KNEW that Andrew was going home. But, Ryan shocked us when he said that Big Mike was going home!!! As Big Mike started singing his swan song, I sat back and watched the judges "debate" on whether or not to use the "save". To my dismay, they decided to use the save on Big Mike. Why, Why, Why?! Crystal may need that save at some point. Why waste it on him? He's WAY too cocky. It's almost hard to watch. The viewers didn't vote for him... send him home! I guess all I can do is hope that he's in the bottom again. All I know is that Crystal better not get sent home now that the save has been used.

Related articles by Zemanta

• Did Idol's Judges Save the Right Guy? (tvwatch.people.com)